January 27, 2010 by Robin Dickinson | 100 views | Comments (16)
Please retweet!

Notes:
The inspiration for this post came from a question I asked on Twitter recently:
Just curious, is asking people to retweet you cool or not cool?
Quite a few people responded with thoughts for and against. For example:
- Not cool at all!
- Usually feel uncomfortable!
- Totally uncool to ask for a retweet.
- Not cool in my opinion. Earn it – if people think it’s good they’ll retweet.
- As long as it is in line with THEIR brand.
- Cool mostly- not all the time but in certain circumstances (philanthropic support or sharing info that could benefit many).
- Only really ok if it’s for a cause needing help/awareness.
- If someone direct messages me & asks, it’s a little sneaky, but looking for a job or lost cat, then appealing for retweet is OK.
Your thoughts…
As a leader who reads this blog, your input to this topic is valued and encouraged.
Feel free to use any or all of the following questions to stimulate your thinking:
Q1: What’s your opinion about people asking you for a retweet?
Q2: What other ‘social rules’, if any, do you abide by on-line?
Q3: How do you handle it if people break or ignore your ‘social rules’?


16 Responses to this post
January 27, 2010 at 6:35 pm |
Retweeting is a funny thing. There are a couple of people I follow on Twitter who i swear feel like the get paid by the retweet. Every post to their Twitter account starts with a RT, or in the case of one individual, she insists on RT every reply to every person @replying her. To me this feels like overusage of the retweet meme and actually quite self indulgent.
Part of me wants to unfollow the pair of them and clean up my stream, but popular opinion has these two as leaders and movers in our local community. So at some point in the future it may be beneficial to me to have them in my circle. Maybe some business opportunity could come from knowing them. So I tollerate the RT abuse.
Asking for a retweet unless for a humanitarian or altruistic cause, is kinda self-indulgent, egotistical and a social faux pas in my opinion. Trying not to be cynical but sometimes the web feels like a shark pool
cheers
January 28, 2010 at 5:16 am |
Thanks, Adam.
That’s a very honest response, and one that I can totally relate to. I’ve experienced that kind of ‘Twitter-tension’ many times.
Just this morning, I have been caught between the two competing forces of wanting to keep following someone because of the value they create and wanting to unfollow them because of ‘excessive’ and unsocial tweet-stream behaviour.
The truth is probably that an element of this tension exists for all of us. I wonder how many of the fine people who ‘follow’ my tweets are torn between going and staying.
Adam, do you ever think we’ll get to the stage where ‘followers’ can just express openly to Twitter buddies what they think and give us feedback – or is that cross another social rule of engagement?
Best to you,
Robin
January 27, 2010 at 10:08 pm |
I think it’s okay to ask for a RT if it’s a good cause or something important that 1st level contacts may not know but 2nd level contacts might.
Adam – admire you for sticking with those two tweeters. That kind of RT overusage you describe would have me unfollowing quickly. “Popular opinion” isn’t always the best opinion. Also, if I’m following someone but not engaging with them or enjoying their tweets, then they’re not really in my circle… (imho)
January 28, 2010 at 5:26 am |
Hi Reeta,
Building on from Adam’s comment, do you attempt any kind of dialog with any of the people you are thinking of unfollowing – e.g. ‘love your tweets, but could you tone it down a bit’ etc?
I guess my point is probably rhetorical, but how do we ever ‘train’ people what is acceptable/unacceptable behaviour for our ‘circle’?
Or is it just faster and easy to unfollow first and ask questions later?
Oh, and I agree wholeheartedly agree with you – “Popular opinion” isn’t always the best opinion.”
Thank you for your contribution, Reeta.
Best days, Robin
January 27, 2010 at 10:26 pm |
Q1: What’s your opinion about people asking you for a retweet?
I generally don’t like people asking for retweets. If a user finds something interesting anyway, and would like their followers to read it, then they can decide themselves whether or not to retweet and pass it on. I can’t remember a time when I have seen some write “please retweet” and that itself has made up my mind to hit the retweet button. That piece of text may make up some users mind but I would imagine it would be a small minority. I can understand why some users do this when they are desperate for their message to be spread but constantly seeing the same “please retweet” message on the end of tweets is not likely to have a positive impact – on me anyway.
Q2: What other ’social rules’, if any, do you abide by on-line?
I try my hardest to credit authors when I make reference to their work. I try not to use colourful language.
Q3: How do you handle it if people break or ignore your ’social rules’?
If someone tries tweeting information as their own or uses language I do not like then I still keep quiet. This is because it is up to the user how they decide to communicate online. People use the platform in different ways and I don’t really have a right to tell them otherwise. I always have the option to unfollow them if I choose to but getting into a discussion about the ways I disagree with another users tweets wouldn’t normally result in a positive outcome. Saying that, if you are reading this and you tweet blog posts/links without crediting the user or at least using “via @” please have another think about why you choose NOT to credit them.
These are all personal viewpoints on individuals using Twitter rather than from a corporate perspective.
January 28, 2010 at 5:40 am |
Hi Robert, and welcome!
My apologies for the delay between you posting your comment and the wretched ‘approval’ process of this blog. Thanks for your patience.
Yes, that’s an excellent point – what impact do the words ‘Please RT’ actually have on our behaviour?
I guess for me, that impact has mostly been negative i.e. mild irritation, except in situations where compassionate/urgent personal reasons kick in and someone really needs help. This is by far the exception to the rule.
If the content is valuable to our community, surely retweeting is a no-brainer??
I totally respect your rule to credit people’s original work. It’s a standard I wish more followed.
Your point about “getting into a discussion about the ways I disagree with another users tweets wouldn’t normally result in a positive outcome.” is interesting and triggers some self-reflection.
The truth is, I probably haven’t had the guts to give someone open feedback about their online behaviour (before even considering whether or not I had the right to). That’s a very interesting distinction, Robert.
At what point, if any, would you feel compelled to give someone feedback about their online behaviour?
Thank you for your stimulating perspectives, Robert.
Best to you, Robin
January 27, 2010 at 11:52 pm |
Social media tools are sometimes abused. Having 1000 friends in Facebook, following 2000 people in Twitter, etc.
I am following 20 people in Twitter and having hard time to catch up with them all, reading all of their tweets, visiting their links.
There are people who establish efficient communications by these tools and there are people who do it just because the trend is so, just because it is fashion.
Asking for re-tweeting is so meaningless. If you add value to people, they will normally re-tweet your posts to add value to their followers.
January 28, 2010 at 5:46 am |
Hey Selcuk, great to see you my friend.
You are a man who builds community – and one who leads with generosity. It’s a fine example you set.
Have you ever had people Direct Message or email you for retweets?
What’s your response to this more ‘personal’ approach for promotional assistance?
Keep up the great creative work, Selcuk.
Best, Robin
January 27, 2010 at 11:57 pm |
Hi Robin,
Q1. I don’t mind getting a retweet request from someone I know pretty well, or if it is for a really good reason. I don’t think people should overdo the RT requests, especially if their purpose is self promotion.
Q2. I have come to loathe automated responses from new follows. I never read them, never send them. Mainly I use social media for business, and I prefer to have more personal conversations via Twitter DM or email. However, I recognize people use social media for all kinds of reasons, and I don’t really judge what they’re doing.
Q3. Like I was saying, on social media we should expect a wide variety of communication styles and objectives. If someone is communicating something in a way that is not consistent with what I’m doing, I’ll probably just ignore them. To me, it’s just noise. By the same token, I’m sure I use social media in ways that drive some folks crazy or puts them off. Unless people are profane or hostile, I say live and let live. All of these comments apply to professional use of social media. People using social media for purely personal reasons – that’s a whole other world. Nice discussion as usual, Robin, et al.
January 28, 2010 at 5:56 am |
Thanks, Brad.
Automated responses and other generic spam do very little for me either. As you say, best ignored. I always wonder about the mindset that drives this kind of behaviour.
So often, the people I least figure to automate are the ones who do it. Do they think we like it?
Building on the discussion above, I totally get the ‘live and let live’ approach to online styles and objectives and remain curious – as our inner community grows in trust and respect, would there ever be a time when we felt ‘safe’ enough – trusted/respected/valued enough – to give someone feedback about their unacceptable behaviour?
Thanks, buddy. Always love to see your posts, comments and tweets.
Best of days, Robin
January 28, 2010 at 2:56 am |
A retweet that’s asked for is like someone asking you for a favour to introduce them with someone in your network.
It works, and it’s fine, and often yields great results. But it’s not the best way.
The best way is to be so compelling, that introductions come to you.
January 29, 2010 at 5:07 am |
Good to see you, mate.
You make a great point – “It works, and it’s fine, and often yields great results.”
And I guess that’s why I see so many people asking for retweets. It reminds me of that old sales adage, ‘You miss out on 100% of the sales you don’t ask for.’
There’s such a fine line between social and antisocial media i.e. doing whatever is necessary to get the results you want and being perceived as aggressive and pushy.
Great to get your inputs, especially as I know you are working so hard to make Like Minds a big success (as I know it will be).
Best to you, Robin
January 29, 2010 at 5:17 am |
Yeah, I’ll come out of hiding sometime soon.
January 28, 2010 at 6:40 am |
Those are some interesting questions – there’s no “reply” next to your name so I’m adding my comment to the bottom of the thread.
I believe that twitter has been clever calling people “followers” because it’s forcing a sense of united community from the word Go. However, twitter followers are more like browsers rather than followers.
It’s kind of like being at a mall where you’ve hand-picked all the people you want in there with you. You’re all interested and looking at each other but you don’t want to commit straight away.
As you watch them, you get annoyed by some, get drawn to others, some make you smile, some make you cringe, and some you hardly see because your eyes don’t reach where they are. But you know they’re there as you can see their shadow.
So unless you have a small group of people or are interacting with people you know in the outside world, I’m not sure it’s appropriate to think of twitter followers as being “your circle”. They’re not. The people you interact with (2-way interaction) could be but with the majority, it’s browsing with the possible future potential of becoming something more.
The ones you regularly engage with are most likely to be already conforming to your personal “twitter standards”. And if they’re not, it’s easier to drop a hint and accept they may tell you where to go!
With the others, because there is no circle (just the illusion of one), there’s no automatic right to train them. They have to use twitter the way they want to.
Remember when we unfollow someone, we can always re-follow them again – we’re not closing any doors except with the more sensitive ones who keep a database of unfollowers (Yes, I know 2 people who do that!!!)
Some people start out using it one way and change as they develop a purpose for being there. Very similar to how we develop in “real” life too.
January 29, 2010 at 4:59 am |
Very nice distinctions, Reeta. My apologies for not being able to link this comment to the above thread.
‘Browsers’ works well for that initial stage of engagement where people are checking each other out.
Your point about refollowing is well made. Many people, myself included, are still finding their social-media legs, and can be hard to follow initially. I have experienced the unfollow/refollow cycle on Twitter many times.
Thanks, Reeta.
Shine on, Robin
Trackbacks